Quick answer to your actual question — a study score under 20 still counts, there's no cut-off where a subject drops out of your ATAR. Your aggregate is your English score plus your next three best scaled scores plus 10% of your 5th and 6th, so a low Spesh score just contributes less, it doesn't vanish. The other thing is your SAC letter grades don't convert directly to a study score — VCAA moderates them against how your class goes on the exam, so your rank in the class matters more than the D itself. And Spesh scales up a lot, so a raw score in the low 20s can still scale up a few points. Honestly though, if Spesh is sitting that low, the exam is where you can still move it — even a mid-range exam lifts the moderated score a fair bit.