also if u have time could anyone rate these 2 pieces, persuasive and narrative, it took me like 30-40 min to write each which is not great but feedback would help

narrative: (crash landing)
I woke in a cold sweat to a clattering sound. Yawning in exasperation, I peered out the window to see that the left wing was vibrating uncontrollably.

“Dear passengers, we are experiencing a bit of turbulence but rest assured we have it completely under control. Sorry for the inconvenience,” the loudspeaker blared.

Shrugging in indifference, I put my eye mask back on my face and began to drift off, thinking it was just a regular occurrence. But then the plane jolted to the side suddenly, sending a shiver through my body. I tried to ignore it and fall asleep, but then I heard a bloodcurdling scream from one of the flight attendants. I ripped the mask off my face to look out the window again, only this time, the wing was missing.

I tried to maintain my composure as the plane began to rapidly descend, but apprehension was creeping into my veins as every second passed. I heard passengers squealing and crying in horror, and I knew there was not much time left before all our lives would be lost. My grandfather, as an expert pilot, would have immediately taken it upon himself to steer the plane to safety. So, as the only passenger who knew how to fly a plane, I got off my seat and hurried to the cockpit, clenching my teeth in fear.

Opening the door to the cabin, I saw that both the pilots had fainted over their steering wheels. Now that I was even more terrified, I tried to take control, when I suddenly felt a tug on my jacket.

“Sir, you cannot go in there! P-please leave this up to the p-pilots, they surely have everything under control-” the flight attendant yelled, her jaw dropping to the floor in fear when she realised the pilots were unconscious.
I took her hand off my shoulder and ignored her plea, grabbing a hold of the steering wheel. The lives of hundreds of people were now in my hands. I closed my eyes and prayed that this would work.

The plane was approaching the ground rapidly, and my hands began to tremble, but a wave of relief washed over me as I saw the runway only a few hundred metres ahead. So, using the skills my grandfather had taught, and with all the power left in my body, I steered the plane up.

The plane hit the runway with a loud crash, as a raucous screech reverberated through the hull. But the plane stopped. Applause started to emerge from the back of the plane. Confused, I looked outside the windscreen to see that we were on the ground. Safely. I ambled out of the seat in disbelief, realising I had just saved hundreds of lives. A soothing sense of solace overcame me, and I collapsed on the floor in enervation and reassurance. My grandfather would be proud.

persuasive: (should euthanasia be legalised) (note: i dont actually agree with this point of view but i couldnt think of supportive reasons for the opposing one without discussing religion)
Imagine that you are lying miserably in a hospital bed with an incurable disease, throbbing in agony, on the brink of death, and praying that the anguish would end soon. In cases like these, and with the permission of the suffering patient, a simple way to fulfil these wishes would be to euthanise the patient. Euthanasia is a quick, effective, and peaceful way to die. I strongly believe that it should be legalised as it does not cause pain to the patient, it enforces human rights, and it is an easier way to end a patient’s torment.

Firstly, the administration of euthanasia is a very gentle process. The chemicals used in euthanasia are similar to those used in anaesthesia, except that these ones override and shut down the body, killing the patient painlessly, all while only taking a single injection. For a person who is already going to die a slow, painful death, euthanasia stands out as a merciful alternative to letting the patient suffer stoically. Putting the patient to rest like this shows compassion and empathy for what they are experiencing, and will make their final moments somewhat bearable.

Furthermore, dignity is a basic human right and must not be ignored even when patients are on the verge of death. It is important to realise that patients who want to be euthanised, and are willingly choosing to die, are going through unbearable pain. Certain diseases and conditions make patients’ lives insufferable, and so the least we can do is allow them to die tranquilly and with dignity.

In addition to the above, euthanasia is above all, an easy way to end a patient’s misery without any ethical implications. The process is simple; the doctor injects chemicals into the body of the patient, and within a few minutes, the patient is dead. On the contrary, keeping the ill patient alive would require a great deal of futile effort and nursing care, not to mention the patient continuing to experience severe pain. Euthanasia would allow the patient to die in peace, without requiring painful repercussions.

Ultimately, I hope you can now see from the arguments listed above that euthanasia should be legalised. It is pain-free, a demonstration of human rights, and a simple way for a suffering patient to be put to rest. After all, everyone should be allowed to die peacefully.

    mhsbandar HELP THE SECOND POINT IS LITERALLY MY POINT BUT PRESENTED SM BETTER I NEED TO LEARN FROM YOU☠️☠️🙏🏻

      a📀 Nah 😅 idk this is my first time marking someone.

        @din you have 5 ENTIRE MINUTES just to plan your single piece, not including the 30 mins of writing time. You can use this to your advantage to create a theme and solid plot line.

        • din replied to this.

          .. also did u get macrob

            a📀 oh sorry i didnt read yours before posting thats mb but thanks

              mhsbandar nah sorry i didn’t mean to say u were copying my point or smth lollll

              • Edited

              .. Yes I will make a solid plot and theme in the planning time from now on.

              mhsbandar Well first off both stories sound really good, its definitely a close standard to what is needed for superior in writing, dw the time management will get better over practice. I don't have much criticism to give but here are some areas I think need working.

              Narrative: The plot point about the grandpa could have been introduced in a small line at the beginning, as in the middle feels a bit sudden. like right after he woke up he could say "man commercial planes have really changed over the decades, my grandpa used to tell me all the intricacies of the flying beauties he flown, sad that he's past now". Or how his grandpa was a airline fanatic idk. You could have also not specified what the flight attendant realised, like more show not tell.

              persuasive: Could have gone more specific as too why dignity is a human right, like what dignity is and its importance in our lives. Also in the third paragraph you could have named the financial and emotional burden of the loved ones of the patient.

                a📀 I'm a male ☠️ I go SCHS, I got in year 10 entry with 4 sup and 1 above average(top 20%)

                  My above average was writing 😅 Probably because I didn't do a single proper practice essay

                  din refrain from using a lot of dialogue, and focus more on description while also carrying the plot onwards, a really cliche term but it's really important in writing - 'show not tell'
                  great vocabulary choice, but do not use such figurative descriptions of the character's actions, try to make it like from 'her mum screamed back in reply' to a 'the booming voice of the mother reverberated in the lounge, the reply rebounding off every wall, kindling the fury of ami' then from 'ami ran out the front door in rage', you could try 'as the voice echoed in her head, a loud slam silenced the adversary hypnotizing.'

                    MHS successful candidate damn 😭 i would recommend to probably get a better understanding of the vocab, and try to apply them in narratives as much as possible for the people who are struggling w/ writing
                    read more books to better construct a complete narrative in your head when doing tests (when given a prompt), as you can understand styles of authors (autuer) and what vocab they use, because major authors normally write a similar genre-based book, so find words of good phrases to copy down and then use if the given narrative prompt is revolving around it, that's what I'll give for narrative construction and vocabulary usage

                      .. mb lmao ur so good damn

                      • .. replied to this.

                        hey can everyone please rate my writing and tell me which grade it will get is sehs. I am currently in yr 8 and in Glen Waverly secondary. Can you also please give deatiled feedback if possible. Thank you.
                        title: You are locked in a room that says: DO NOT OPEN
                        I blinked open my eyes. I spun around, scrutinizing every inch of the room, which apparently had no door. I was simply locked in.
                        At the very corner of my eye, I saw a small wooden box. It was full of moss and covered in cobwebs. I carefully tipped forward and blew on the box to get rid of the dust. The box had giant, dark red letters scrawled across it:

                        "DO NOT OPEN!"

                        My mind was spinning. I pondered whether I should open the box. My thoughts inched closer and closer to temptation. A quote surfaced in my mind:

                        "Curiosity isn’t a sin, but caution should always come first."

                        But at that moment, my body didn’t care. I pounded forward and thrust open the great, heavy lid.

                        Immediately, I started coughing. Dust billowed out like smoke, swirling around me like the aftermath of a meteor crash. I waved my hands, trying to clear the air.

                        "There is nothing in this stupid box," I thought savagely and turned away.

                        I was stuck. Forever.

                        I curled up on the cold, hard ground, hoping this was all just a nightmare. Just as I was drifting off…

                        A raspy voice creaked, "Leave this place now!"

                        I jerked awake, my eyes darting frantically around the room.

                        "I was probably dreaming," I thought, hopefully.

                        Suddenly, another voice cackled maniacally and whispered, "No, stay. You are trapped, and there is nothing you can do about it."

                        I froze. My pupils widened in horror. My heart slammed against my ribs.

                        "Go to the box," a hoarse voice choked out.

                        I bolted towards it. My hands trembled as I lifted the lid once more—and to my bemusement, a small trapdoor lay hidden inside.

                        Without thinking, I flung it open and scrambled inside, crawling desperately through the narrow tunnel. My breath came in ragged gasps. The walls were cold, damp, and suffocating, but I kept pushing forward.

                        And then—light.

                        I burst outside, gasping for air. My legs wobbled as I stood up, and I instinctively turned back toward the place I had just escaped from.

                        It wasn’t a room. It wasn’t even a box.

                        It was a massive steel container.

                        Etched across the surface in bold, eerie letters were the words:

                        "SCIENTIFIC EXPERIMENTS."

                          Messithegoat1234 maybe turn ur sentences into paragraphs by like combining them I guess, atleast like 5 paragraphs should be good. Rather than saying how u felt maybe u could "show" like instead of saying my legs wobbled u could say smth like, "my legs were noodles" and instead of the person escaping, maybe he could stay trappe. for increased tension.

                          a📀 ty

                          .. thanks for the feedback, this clarifies a lot of things i was confused about

                          din alg! js lemme know if u have any more questions 😃

                          • din likes this.

                          MHS successful candidate oh ok thanks for that
                          just to clarify: instead of a sentence saying "I strongly/firmly/staunchly believe that dogs should not be kept on leashes," i should just say "dogs should not be kept on leashes"

                            wait what did I miss out on again😭🙏

                            • .. replied to this.

                              Dosanjh (NHS) nothing much, jus people giving suggestions to other people's writing.

                                do u guys have any creative writing prompts for me to use pls

                                Messithegoat1234

                                you are doing too uch telling . Do showing the actions and emotions

                                19 days later

                                asianasen thank you so much i just want to see what qualilty of writing is needed yk what i mean